Action and Heartbreak the Focal Point of New Moon
Christa Banister : Crosswalk.com Contributing Writer

Surprisingly, with the exception of one particular fight scene that was created specifically for the movie, the story remains remarkably faithful to Stephenie Meyer's book, an anomaly in most book to big-screen transitions, something that will undoubtedly please the majority of fans. Although considering how downright giddy the girls were at my particular screening, I'm guessing that simply seeing heartthrobs Robert Pattinson and Taylor Lautner back on the big screen was satisfying enough.

Still, even with all the right elements working well together, there's still something not entirely satisfying about New Moon, and ultimately, the flaw definitely lies in the source material. No matter how much someone suspends his/her disbelief, as one has to do when watching a movie about a vampire romancing a human, it's still impossible to overlook the fact that we still don't know what exactly Bella loves so much about Edward (other than his stunning looks) that she'd make that kind of sacrifice (and vice versa, considering the whole vampire/human tension for him) because it never was fully explored.

Sure, a superficial kind of love is enough to sustain most romantic comedies because it's all about the girl getting the guy or the guy getting the girl. But if the story is going to continue beyond the chase, there simply has to be something more substantial at stake to make it even remotely worthwhile. And unfortunately, that pursuit of true love, built on real, lasting qualities just isn't there in New Moon, despite the story's many engaging qualities on the surface.

CAUTIONS:

  • Drugs/Alcohol:  Bella's dad is shown drinking beer.
  • Smoking:  None.
  • Language/Profanity:  The words "hel-" and "dam-" are used from time to time. 
  • Sex/Nudity:  There are no sex scenes, just a few kisses exchanged between Bella and Edward. Other than Jacob and Edward's occasional shirtlessness, there's also no nudity. 
  • Violence:  Upping the ante from the first Twilight installment in the violence department, there's a decapitation of a vampire. Edward is later thrown around and abused by the Volturi. A group of Italian tourists (including children) are sacrificed by the Volturi (thankfully, the action, save for the sounds of screaming, takes place offscreen). There are some scary moments once the werewolves emerge—and as they fight with the vampires. Edward and Bella's love story almost takes a Romeo and Juliet-esque turn when Edward fears that Bella is dead. 
  • Rebellion:  When Edward breaks up with Bella, Bella is so heartbroken that she starts acting out. First she's trying her hand at motorcycling, then cliff-diving. At one point, she goes on a motorcycle ride with a smarmy-looking stranger, hoping that Edward will appear to her.

Christa Banister is a full-time freelancer writer, specializing in music, movies and books-related reviews and interviews and is the author of two novels, Around the World in 80 Dates and Blessed Are the Meddlers. Based in St. Paul, Minn., she also weighs in on various aspects of pop culture on her personal blog

For more information, including her upcoming book signings and sample chapters of her novels, check out her Website.

 

Content provided by http://www.crosswalk.com/
Page  «  <  >  »      1  2  
 
Add Your Comment
Please login to post your comment

Reader Comments
danielle2412/13/2009 7:05 PM
I like that there aren't many explanations for why Bella and Edward love each other. In following with the story's allusion to Romeo and Juliet, I prefer the theme of predestination as the qualifier for their love. Bella seems predestined to be loved by a nonhuman entity because she has unnatural immunities to their powers. It's that age-old theme of fate.

Sometimes I get tired of culture's repeated theme to be better and to earn love. It's a breath of fresh air to be told a story in which someone is loved--yes romantically loved--because God created them as the person they are. And in real romantic relationships love oftentimes does feel undeserved. How can we deserve something so wonderful? And besides it's not like Bella is a bad person or anything. It may not work for all stories, but I think for this love story predestination isn't so out of place or even shallow as some think. Undeserved love, grace as the Bible calls it, is refreshing sometimes.
Login to Report This PostLogin to Report This Post

danielle2412/13/2009 7:02 PM
I like that there aren't many explanations for why Bella and Edward love each other. In following with the story's allusion to Romeo and Juliet, I prefer the theme of predestination as the qualifier for their love. Bella seems predestined to be loved by a nonhuman entity because she has unnatural immunities to their powers. It's that age-old theme of fate.

Sometimes I get tired of culture's repeated theme to be better and to earn love. It's a breath of fresh air to be told a story in which someone is loved--yes romantically loved--because God created them as the person they are. And in real relationships love oftentimes does feel undeserved. And besides it's not like Bella is a bad person or anything. It may not work for all stories, but I think for this love story predestination isn't so out of place or even shallow as some think. Undeserved love, grace as the Bible calls it, is refreshing sometimes.
Login to Report This PostLogin to Report This Post

danielle2412/13/2009 6:59 PM
I like that there aren't many explanations for why Bella and Edward love each other. In following with the story's allusion to Romeo and Juliet, I prefer the theme of predestination as the qualifier for their love. Bella seems predestined to be loved by a nonhuman entity because she has unnatural immunities to their powers. It's more that she is fated to be with Edward.

I prefer predestination to Bella and Edward earning each other's love through having great characteristics or values. Sometimes I get tired of culture's repeated theme to be better and to earn love. It's a breath of fresh air to be told a story in which someone is loved because God created them as the person they are. And besides it's not like Bella is a bad person or anything. It may not work for all stories, but I think for this love story predestination isn't so out of place or even shallow as some think. Undeserved love, grace as the Bible calls it, is refreshing sometimes.
Login to Report This PostLogin to Report This Post


Report This Post
Username:      If this isn't your username, click here.
Comment Author:
Comment:
Reason:
Priority:
Please type your explanation in the space below.
Report This Post
Your report has been sent.
free newslettersfree newsletters
Stay informed on the latest in pop culture from a Christian perspective
To receive email newsletters, updates and special offers from TheFish, select your newsletter(s), enter your email address and hit "Sign Up".
Privacy Policy / Terms of Use
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Get the week’s highlights reviews, interviews and more!
  • The fastest entertainment features and blogs every day!
  • Catch the latest review of new films in the theater and on DVD.
  • All the latest reviews and artist interviews every week.
  • Our writers comment on the latest pop culture news.
AVERAGE READER RATING
How would you rate this article?
communitycommunity
 
Remember Me